Day 22of 28, Capablanca's Chess Career

How to Win Bishop Endings: Control the Transition First

Nimzowitsch vs Capablanca · Riga 1913 · Controlling the Transition to the Endgame

Everyone knows that opposite-colored bishop endings are drawn. Aron Nimzowitsch knew it, and he steered for one on purpose. Capablanca knew something better: he had been preparing that ending since the queens came off, and he called this game "one of the finest endings I ever played." The lesson here is bigger than one ending. Chess is taught as three phases, but there are really five, and the two most players never think about are the transitions between them. Capablanca wins this game in the transition from middlegame to endgame, by asking a question most players do not ask: which endgame do I want? Take one idea from this game: the moment the queens come off in your games, stop playing a middlegame. Bring your king in, put your pawns on the right color, and steer toward the ending you can win.

Three ideas you'll take from this endgame
01

Five phases, not three

Between opening, middlegame and endgame there are two transitions, and you must conduct yourself differently in each. The moment the queens come off, ask which endgame you are heading for.

02

Queens off, king in

In the opening and middlegame your king stays safe. In the transition it becomes a fighting piece. Ask how it gets in, and what job it will do when it arrives.

03

Pawns on the right color

Capablanca's principle for bishop endings: put your pawns on the opposite color to your bishop. There is one exception, the defender in opposite-colored bishop endings, who wants them on his own bishop's color.

Study Mode: Watch & Play Along

Watch the lesson, then play the game through on the board below. The board stays with you as you scroll. Make each move yourself while you read. You'll remember a plan you played with your own hands far longer than one you only watched.

▶ The Lesson
♞ Play Through the Game: The Board Stays With You
The Big Idea

Which endgame do you want?

When bishops of opposite color are on the board they can never trade, and that creates a very particular imbalance. If White attacks on the dark squares, White in effect has an extra piece. If Black attacks on the light squares, Black has one. So those bishops are not a guarantee of a draw. They are a guarantee of a target, for whichever side has the better pawns and the better king. Nimzowitsch saw opposite bishops and thought: safe. Capablanca saw the same bishops and began to arrange the whole board for them. His pawns went to dark squares, taking control of the squares his own bishop could not touch. Yes, that gives the White bishop something to look at, and he accepted that risk with his eyes open. His king walked in. And then he traded down, again and again, to the very ending the defender thought was his way out. Nimzowitsch, meanwhile, pushed pawns onto light squares, exactly where the black bishop could attack them. Every one of those pushes is a mistake a principle could have prevented, and every one of them is a mistake you can stop making.

How the Endgame Arose

A bold game in Riga, and a date in dispute

First, the date, because the sources do not agree. The book heads this game Riga, January or February 1914; the study record says 30 December 1913. I use 1913 here and neither source can settle it. Capablanca calls the opening a Four Knights; with 4.Bc4 it is really an Italian. 7.Bb5, moving a developed piece a second time, gave up the better 7.Nd5. Then came the course that shocked the spectators, among them Nimzowitsch's father, as Capablanca tells it: 11...g5 and 12...Nxe4, a pawn up with his king still in the center. Here you see a key point about phases. In a middlegame full of pieces, that king would be a serious target. Capablanca recommended 13.Qd3 to keep it one, and I like that idea: 13...Nxg3 14.fxg3 opens the f-file. The engine calls the two moves about level, but the choice matters. You need about three pieces to attack a king successfully, and Nimzowitsch traded instead with 13.Bxc6 and went after the lost pawn: 14.dxe5 dxe5 15.Bxe5 Qxd1 16.Raxd1. The queens are off. Material is level, and the danger to the black king has gone. The lesson begins here.

Stop and Assess

The queens have just come off. What about your king?

Your king is on e8 and you still have the right to castle. For the whole game so far the correct instinct has been to get it safe. But look at what has just changed: the queens have gone, White's attack has gone with them, and the bishops of opposite color tell you what kind of ending is coming. Before you read on, write down three candidate moves, compare them, and rank them good, better, best. Then ask: what job should the king have from here on?

Black to play after 16.Raxd1. What is your plan for your king?

This one is graded by reasoning. The bishop on e5 is hitting the rook on h8, so you must deal with that too. Which move does both jobs at once? Think, then reveal.

Nimzowitsch vs Capablanca, after 16.Raxd1: the queens are off and Black must decide what to do with the king.
After 16.Raxd1 the queens are off. Should Black castle, or does the king have a better job?
Reveal the assessment

What Nimzowitsch hopes

  • Opposite bishops. He believes they give him a safe game whatever else happens. Capablanca says as much in his note.
  • A simple recovery. He has won his pawn back, and material is level.
  • The c7 pawn. After 16...f6 he could take on c7, and that was his better chance. He played 17.Bd4 instead, and the engine says that cost him about a pawn.

Capablanca's answer: 16...f6 and ...Kf7

  • It asks the question. 16...f6 hits the bishop on e5 and clears f7 for the king in a single move. Capablanca calls it the key, counted on when he played ...g5.
  • The king walks toward the center. Castling would take it away from the place it will be needed, though castling is also a reasonable move.
  • The engine's first choice. It is 16...f6, narrowly ahead of castling, and the gap grows after 17.Bd4 Kf7. As Capablanca put it, the black king is now the more useful of the two.
The Plan

Trade toward the ending your opponent thinks is safe

Watch what Capablanca does with the middle of this game. 18...Rhe8 is a decision: he trades the knights, knowing perfectly well that opposite bishops are what will remain. Now look at Nimzowitsch. 21.g4 pushes a pawn from a worse position, onto a light square, and the engine confirms the damage. My advice for your games is simple: do not push pawns where you stand weaker, because each push leaves a weakness behind. 21...Bb5 hits the f1 rook before he can get f4 in, and 23...Re2 offers a trade of rooks. After 24.Rxe2 Bxe2 25.Re1 Bxf3 26.Rf1 comes the one move that gives Black the advantage by force, 26...c5, hitting the d4 bishop while the f3 bishop hangs. If 27.Rxf3 cxd4 28.Rd3 Rc8, then for all practical purposes Black is a pawn ahead, as Capablanca says. Nimzowitsch chose 27.Bxf6 to keep the opposite bishops. And here the engine catches both players, as I said on camera. Capablanca played 27...Rd1, trading the last rooks. The stronger move was 27...Kxf6 28.Rxf3+ Ke5: a rook ending with level pawns, in which Black's king and rook are so active that the engine rates it far above the game. In my view Capablanca tended to avoid rook endings that needed long calculation, and he did not compare the candidates here. The Goldilocks principle would have shown it. In your games, I still want you to take the lesson he intended: choosing an ending you know how to win is a real skill. After 28.Be5 Rxf1+ 29.Kxf1 Bxg4 Black is a pawn up. He wrote that the ending was now won by force. The engine agrees it is winning, without any forced proof. Months later Nimzowitsch told him he had found a draw, and Capablanca, who had not looked at the game since, bet him a small sum, giving him draw odds from any position from here on. In a few moves Nimzowitsch saw his idea was wrong and gave up. Then 30.a4, onto a light square again, for no reason at all.

The Critical Moment: Think First

The rooks are gone and this is the pure opposite-colored bishop ending, the one everyone calls a draw. Nimzowitsch has pushed his pawn to a4, and now 31.Bb8 attacks the pawn on a7. Moving the king or pushing a kingside pawn simply loses a7 and most of Black's winning chances, so the a-pawn has to move. There are two ways to do that. Both win, according to the engine, and one is stronger. As always, the why matters more than the move.

Black to play. The bishop attacks your a-pawn. Which pawn move do you play, and why?

Nimzowitsch vs Capablanca, after 31.Bb8: Black to play and decide how to answer the attack on a7.
After 31.Bb8 the a7 pawn is attacked. Which square does it go to, and why?
Reveal the move and the why

31...a5, fixing the target. Do not rush to win the a4 pawn. Nail it down first. On a5 the black pawn stops the a4 pawn forever: it cannot move, it cannot be defended by another pawn, and it stands on the black bishop's color, where it can be collected at leisure. And the pawn on a5 cannot be attacked in return, because 32.Bc7 runs into 32...b5! 33.axb5 a4, when the pawn runs. Capablanca noted that 31...a6 would also have won, taking much longer, and the engine agrees that it wins, less clearly. His note can also be read as saying that a6 answers the alternative 31.Bg7. If so, the engine disagrees: 31.Bg7 a6 32.Bxh6 is level. Against 31.Bg7 the right reply is 31...h5, which keeps the win. Now see the whole picture. Black's pawns on a5, b6 and c5 stand on dark squares in a chain. They control the squares his own bishop cannot reach, and they leave the White bishop very little to do. After 32.Ke1 Kd5 33.Kd2 Bd7 34.Bc7 Kc6 White cannot take on a5, because 35.Bxa5 b6 traps the bishop against his own c3 pawn. So 35.Bd8 b6 36.c4 Kb7 37.Kc3 Bxa4 and the first target falls. Fix the target, then take it. You do not have to calculate every variation; you only have to recognize a fixed weakness and know it cannot run away. In your own games, when your opponent's pawn is on your bishop's color, ask how to fix it there before you ask how to win it.

♞ Follow the Finish: The Board Returns
Two Passed Pawns

One king and one bishop cannot be everywhere

A single extra pawn usually does not win an ending like this: the White bishop and king can blockade it. So Capablanca creates a second front. After 42...g4 and 44...a3 comes the famous finish, the position that appears in puzzle books, 45...Bxc4+. There are other winning moves here, but this is the prettiest and the most instructive. The king should not take: after 46.Kxc4 a2 47.Be5 h4 48.Kb3 g3 49.hxg3 h3, the bishop no longer controls h2, because its own pawn on g3 stands in the way. One of the two rook's pawns will queen. Nimzowitsch took the a-pawn instead with 46.Kxa3, and Black simply goes on to make a fresh passer on the b-file: 46...b5 47.c3 Kd5.

Nimzowitsch vs Capablanca, after 45...Bxc4+: taking the bishop loses even faster.
After 45...Bxc4+ taking is worse: 46.Kxc4 a2 and one of the rook pawns queens

The king goes in, the b-pawn advances, and then comes the second breakthrough: 57...h4 58.Ke3 g3 59.hxg3 h3. That last move is the only way to win, and the natural recapture 59...hxg3 would let the win slip away. Now Black has passed pawns on the b-file and the h-file, a whole board apart, and only one White king and one bishop to stop them. That is the technique that beats the opposite-bishop fortress: not one passed pawn, but two, too far apart for one defender. After 60.Kf2 Bf5 61.g4 Bxg4 62.Kg3 Kd3 White resigned. In the book the game stops here; the study plays two more moves. Think of the golf saying, drive for show, putt for dough. Capablanca was not always the most accurate player in this game, in the opening or at move 27. He simply knew what he was aiming for in the ending, and that is the part you can copy.

Nimzowitsch vs Capablanca, final position after 62...Kd3: White resigned.
The final position after 62...Kd3. Two passed pawns a board apart, and White resigned
Principles to Take to Your Own Board

This game is over. Your games are where it matters.

1 · Know which phase you are in.

The principle: there are five phases, and the transitions between them ask for different behavior. In this game: Capablanca's uncastled king was fine because the queens and attackers had gone. In your games: when the queens come off, stop and ask which endgame you want.

2 · When queens come off, bring your king in.

The principle: the king is a fighting piece in the endgame. In this game: 16...f6 and 17...Kf7 made the black king the more useful of the two. In your games: it does not always have to go at once, but you must know where it is going and why.

3 · Pawns on the opposite color to your bishop.

The principle: this is Capablanca's principle for bishop endings. It grows your influence and removes targets. The one exception is the defender in an opposite-colored bishop ending, who wants them on his own bishop's color. In this game: Nimzowitsch's a4 and g4 did the reverse. In your games: before you push, check the color.

4 · Do not push pawns where you are weaker.

The principle: a pawn cannot move backward, so when you stand worse, every push is a new weakness. In this game: 21.g4 and 30.a4 both became targets. In your games: improve your pieces first.

5 · Fix the target, then make a second passer.

The principle: fix weaknesses before you collect them, and in opposite-bishop endings win with two passed pawns far apart. In this game: 31...a5, then passers on the b-file and h-file. In your games: one passer is stopped, the other queens. Principles are a general guide. Nothing replaces calculation.

Test Yourself

Five questions before you go

1 · Are opposite-colored bishop endings always a draw?

No. They are drawn far more often than other endings, even a pawn or two down, because the defender can often set up a blockade on squares the attacker's bishop cannot touch. But that is not automatic. If the defender's pawns stand on the attacker's color, they become permanent targets, and if the attacker can create two passed pawns far enough apart, one defender cannot stop both. Nimzowitsch thought the bishops themselves would save him. It was his pawns and his king that decided the game.

2 · What is Capablanca's principle for bishop endings?

Put your pawns on the opposite color to your bishop. It grows your bishop's influence, because the pawns take care of the squares the bishop cannot reach, and it removes targets from your opponent's bishop. It can also fix your opponent's pawns on your bishop's color. With opposite bishops the attacker's pawns can be attacked by the other bishop, a risk he accepts for the control they give. There is one exception: the defending side in an opposite-colored bishop ending puts his pawns on the same color as his own bishop, to take them out of the attacker's reach. Nimzowitsch, defending, should have been putting his on dark squares. He put them on light ones.

3 · What are the five phases of a chess game?

Opening, the transition from opening to middlegame, middlegame, the transition from middlegame to endgame, and endgame. It matters because your priorities change. In this game, with a board full of pieces, a king in the center is a big problem. With the queens gone and only a few pieces left, the same king is an asset that should head for the middle. Much of Capablanca's advantage here came from understanding that change before his opponent did.

4 · Why was the king recapture at move 27 stronger?

Because 27...Kxf6 28.Rxf3+ Ke5 gives Black a rook ending in which the pawns are level but the king is about to march in and the rook has the open file. Rook endings live on activity, and here Black has all of it. The engine prefers it clearly to the game's 27...Rd1. So this is a place to be honest about Capablanca. He steered for the ending he understood, and he won it, but he did not compare the candidates. In your games, it is fine to choose the ending you know, as long as you have looked at the other one first.

5 · What is the one habit this game should change?

Treating the queen trade as just another move. Most players carry on with the same plan after the queens come off. Train yourself to pause at that moment and ask three questions: what endgame am I heading for, where does my king belong, and which color should my pawns be on? Capablanca was asking those questions from move 16, with the ending still many moves away. That is how he beat Nimzowitsch in an ending that everyone, including Nimzowitsch, thought was a draw.

Sharpen Your Eye: Six Endgame Exercises

Now you convert the edge

Six opposite-colored bishop endings, rising in difficulty. In each one the win comes from the king or a passed pawn, not the bishops; find the way through and play it out. Drag the pieces; the board answers for the defense.

Capablanca Knew Which Ending He Wanted. Do You?

Endgame decisions begin long before the endgame, and they are one of the first things I look at. In a 2-hour Strategy Assessment I go through your games personally and build you a roadmap for your chess, not a textbook student's.

Book Your $130 Strategy Assessment 2 hours via Zoom · Worldwide · Limited spots
Next in the series: Capablanca against a team of players, and what his evaluation skills can teach you.